EFFECT OF IN-LINE DRINKING WATER CHLORINATION AT THE POINT OF COLLECTION ON CHILD DIARRHOEA IN URBAN BANGLADESH: A DOUBLE-BLIND, CLUSTER-RANDOMISED CONTROLLED TRIAL
EFFECT OF IN-LINE DRINKING WATER CHLORINATION AT THE POINT OF COLLECTION ON CHILD DIARRHOEA IN URBAN BANGLADESH: A DOUBLE-BLIND, CLUSTER-RANDOMISED CONTROLLED TRIAL
Publication Year:
2019
Authors:
Pickering, Amy J; Crider, Yoshika; Sultana, Sonia; Swarthout, Jenna; Goddard, Frederick GB; Anjerul Islam, Syed; Sen, Shreyan; Ayyagari, Raga; Luby, Stephen P
Language:
English
Affiliated Orgs.:
International Centre for Diarrhoeal Diseases Research Bangladesh
Resource Type:
Journal Article
In a Bangladesh trial, chlorine devices were added to water points to combat child diarrhoea. Results showed a reduction from 10% in the control to 7.5% in the treated group. Passive chlorination at collection points could be a viable strategy for safer water in low-income urban areas. Funded by The World Bank.
Share to:
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
WhatsApp
Reddit
Resource Information
Abstract
Most previous water treatment trials in low-income countries have evaluated point-of-use water treatment technologies used at the household level, potentially because of a previous absence of reliable technologies appropriate to treat water at the community level in low-resource settings. A meta-analysis published in 2018 estimated that point-of-use chlorination reduces diarrhoea prevalence by 24%; however, the effect was diminished and non-significant when adjusted for bias from non-blinding. The few published blinded trials assessing the effect of water treatment interventions in low-income countries have failed to detect an effect on diarrhoea. A Cochrane review published at the start of our trial in 2015 by Clasen and others concluded that further studies were needed to evaluate the effect of chlorination at the point of collection (ie, at community level) on diarrhoea. Our results contribute new evidence to the literature in several ways. First, whereas previous blinded trials have failed to detect health effects, our trial estimated a significant reduction in child diarrhoea in a low-income setting. In addition, whereas many previous water intervention trials have focused on household- level water treatment, our findings show that a low-cost automatic point-of-collection (community-level) water treatment intervention can achieve high uptake and reduce diarrhoea in a densely populated setting. Finally, our results suggest that targeting a low chlorine residual dose (0·3–0·5 ppm) in an effort to increase taste acceptability of chlorinated water can still improve water quality and reduce the risk of diarrhoea.
Resource Type
Journal Article
Publication Year
2019
Author
Pickering, Amy J; Crider, Yoshika; Sultana, Sonia; Swarthout, Jenna; Goddard, Frederick GB; Anjerul Islam, Syed; Sen, Shreyan; Ayyagari, Raga; Luby, Stephen P
Language
English
Organizational Affiliation
International Centre for Diarrhoeal Diseases Research Bangladesh
Relevant Country
Bangladesh
Specific Contaminants
Bacteria, Total coliform, Escherichia coli
Specific Solutions
Aquatabs Flo
University Affiliation
Tufts University, Stanford University, University of California Berkeley, Emory University
Business Connect Takeaways
The study evaluated the effectiveness of in-line drinking water chlorination in reducing child diarrhoea in urban Bangladesh. The study was a double-blind, cluster-randomised controlled trial that included baseline data collection, randomisation and intervention delivery, and up to 14 months of follow-up data collection.
The results of the study showed that in-line drinking water chlorination was effective in reducing child diarrhoea in urban Bangladesh. The intervention reduced the incidence of diarrhoea by 22% and the prevalence of faecal contamination by 68%. In-line chlorination was also found to be more cost-effective than other household water treatment interventions.
The potential implications of this technology for improving public health in low-income settings beyond Bangladesh are significant. In-line drinking water chlorination is a low-cost, low-maintenance technology that can disinfect drinking water without electricity. This technology has the potential to improve access to safe drinking water and reduce the burden of diarrhoeal disease in many low-income settings around the world.